the student who already agrees with you

Every critique has one of these. You point out that the hierarchy is flat, that nothing on the page tells the eye where to land first, and before you finish the sentence they are nodding. Vigorously. “Yeah, no, totally. I knew that. I was actually going to fix that.” They agreed with you before you had made an argument. This should feel like a win. It rarely does. I used to enjoy this student. Easy critique, no resistance, and we could move on to the next project in half the time. It took me a while to notice that their work changed less than anyone else’s, despite all the agreement. Eventually I understood why. Agreeing with a critique and absorbing it are two different acts. The fast nod is usually a sign that the second one never happened.

The nod is not understanding. It is an exit strategy.

If you agree quickly enough, the conversation about your work gets to end, and you get to keep whatever private theory you already had about it. It is not quite listening. Not quite resisting. It is a polite way of leaving the room while still sitting in it. I once told a student her spacing was inconsistent across the layout. “Totally, yeah, I see it.” Which line, I asked. She looked at the page for a genuinely long time and said, “The… second one?” It was not the second one. It was not any of the ones she guessed next. She had agreed with a criticism she had not yet located.

I don’t think this is dishonesty. I think it is a social reflex, the same one that makes people say “that makes sense” in meetings about things that do not yet make sense to them. Agreement is cheap. Disagreement costs time and social capital, and asking a question costs the most of all. So now, when the nodding starts too early, I stop and ask them to point. Physically, on the page, to the exact thing we are discussing. It is a small, slightly unkind test. It also works better than any amount of explaining, because you cannot fake pointing at something you have not actually seen.

Most students find the real problem eventually, usually a little embarrassed, usually somewhere they were not looking.

That embarrassment is a much better sign than the nod ever was. It means that, for once, they were listening to the page instead of to me.

Margin note: The next time you hear yourself say “totally, I see it,” put your finger on the page before you say anything else. If you can’t, say so. It is the most useful sentence in a critique.

Teams nod too, usually in meetings with more people and higher stakes. That is one of the habits we work on in the Digital Product Design workshop. See the workshops →

Previous
Previous

On feedback at the wrong altitude

Next
Next

The first lesson I teach every year